Bought before and smelt so good. These have a more earthy smell I guess you could say. My boy still likes them but not as excited for these as he was for the previous bag. Still best sweet potato treat I’ve been able to find for him so thank you!This is the second bag I’ve received that had mold on the product. I gave it a 3 star only because I’ve had other bags that were just fine, but the latest have had mold and I’ve had to throw them out. After two times of experiencing this and $36 of waste, I won’t be ordering this product online anymore.It took too long to receiveMY DOG LOVED THESE TREATS. However, she does not have all her teeth, so she swallowed larger chunks of them. She is an older dog -- and they backed up in her system...not a happy time for us. BUT, WE DID PASS THEM ON TO MY SISTER IN LAW FOR HER DOGS. They are younger and have all their teeth -- love them and are good for them.These are so hard and crunchy, I could never give to my small dog.Good product and good customer service.My dog is a relatively picky eater- however she absolutely loved these treats. They took her a couple minutes to eat, so they worked as a good distraction when I would leave the house.The treats are thin and small, we were looking for a better treat.